Epic CEO Tim Sweeney clashed with asset artist Kenney on X over generative AI, sparking hundreds of comments. The dispute began with a post where Kenney encouraged developers not to let billionaires convince them about AI. Sweeney responded promptly and quite emphatically.
What happened between Sweeney and Kenney?
Kenney is known for giving away thousands of game assets for free. In his post, he wrote, among other things: “Don’t let billionaires convince you slop is the future.” According to PC Gamer, this was actually a reaction to a statement by Elon Musk and was primarily intended to reach other artists who feel pressured to use AI.
Hours later, Tim Sweeney, head of Epic Games, appeared in the replies. He wrote: “This is bullshit, Kenney” and concluded his retort with “Up yours!” Elon Musk sided with Sweeney. Hundreds of other comments from all sides of the AI debate followed.
What are the arguments of both sides?
- Kenney states that AI certainly has its uses, but he considers it immoral in its current state due to environmental impacts, data centers, training data, and the consequences for almost every industry.
- Sweeney sees it as Epic's mission to showcase the positive side of AI. He warns that studios guided by anti-AI campaigns could marginalize themselves in the global market. He anticipates productivity gains of at least a factor of 2 to 4.
- Kenney counters: If AI truly had mass acceptance already, there would be no need to try and convince him. And regarding the accusation that those who don't participate will be left behind, he says: “Please, leave me behind.”
How significant is skepticism towards AI in games really?
Sweeney claims that criticism of AI comes from a vocal minority. The data is mixed, as PC Gamer notes. According to a GameDiscoverCo survey of Steam users, about 69 percent are neutral or positive about purchasing games with disclosed AI use. At the same time, most users check these disclosures before buying, and over 55 percent even want stricter disclosure rules. Sweeney rejects Steam's mandatory disclosure, calling it “abhorrent.”
Sentiment within the industry is also divided. Developer Dead Teapot, according to PC Gamer, canceled its release on the Epic Games Store in solidarity with Kenney. Epic itself, however, is fully committed to AI-powered development, for example, with the next Unreal Engine version.
Our assessment: The dispute reveals less a conflict over technology than over expectations. Sweeney sells tools to the entire industry and has an interest in seeing them used. Kenney relies on donations and a $20 pack with 60,000 assets, representing the opposing model. Both viewpoints have their merits, but a majority opinion cannot be derived from the numbers. How this plays out in practice is also shown by the debate about disclosure for mods, which we reported on at Nexus Mods and the new AI disclosure.
Those who wish to read the survey themselves can find it in the GameDiscoverCo newsletter.
Source: PC Gamer
Who do you agree with: Sweeney, who sees AI as the future of game development, or Kenney, who prefers to “be left behind”?
Comments (0)
No comments yet — be the first to share your take.