Sony has secured a major victory in a London court: The Competition Appeal Tribunal has completely dismissed the UK class action lawsuit concerning the PlayStation Store. The case most recently involved approximately $2.6 billion. The plaintiffs had accused Sony of operating a de facto monopoly on digital PlayStation games through its own store and charging exorbitant fees.
What was the PlayStation Store lawsuit about?
The lawsuit was spearheaded by consumer advocate Alex Neill with the PlayStation You Owe Us campaign. It was filed in August 2022, representing UK customers who purchased digital content via the PlayStation Store between August 2016 and February 2026. According to Kotaku, this amounts to around nine million people.
The core accusation was that because no third-party stores are permitted on PlayStation, Sony held a “near-monopoly” position for digital games and add-on content. This was compounded by strict developer guidelines and the 30 percent commission Sony retains from every purchase. The result, according to the plaintiffs, was “excessive and unfair prices” that were disproportionate to costs.
The demanded sum fluctuated significantly over the years. In 2022, $5.9 billion was on the table, and in 2023, even $7.9 billion. In May 2026, the amount was reduced to $2.6 billion.

System market instead of PS5 cage: How the Tribunal justified its ruling
According to The Game Business, cited by Kotaku and Insider Gaming, the lawsuit failed to prove that PlayStation violated competition law. The key points of the justification include:
- No ecosystem prison: The plaintiffs argued that PlayStation owners are trapped within the system. The court, however, views Sony as competing in a broader “system market” with Xbox, Nintendo, and PC.
- Physical games as an alternative: Those who do not wish to buy from the PS Store can still opt for disc versions.
- No obligation for external stores: Introducing third-party stores to the console would be expensive and complex, and could compromise security. According to the Tribunal, there is no legal obligation to do so.
- Margins not proven: Neill could not demonstrate that Sony’s profit margins are excessive, especially since console manufacturers sell hardware cheaply and recoup costs through games.
- No evidence of lower prices: There was no evidence that competing stores would have lowered prices.
The lawsuit was thus dismissed in its entirety. The court collects the procedural documents on the Competition Appeal Tribunal’s case page.
From interim victory to defeat: The long road of the lawsuit
This is a bitter outcome for the plaintiffs: For a long time, things looked quite promising. In November 2023, Sony failed in its attempt to have the lawsuit dismissed early, and in January 2024, the proceedings were certified as a class action. Sony also failed before the Court of Appeal in July 2025, when the corporation challenged the plaintiffs' funding agreements. And according to Kotaku, Sony lost a very similar case in California in May 2026, which involved $7.8 billion. Only now, after the main proceedings, has the tide turned in London.
The security argument is interesting: Google did not succeed with this exact argument in its dispute with Epic in the USA, where third-party app stores must now be allowed in Google Play. The British Tribunal, however, sided with Sony's console, maintaining that a closed system is legitimate.

Will PS5 players get money back now?
In short: No. With this ruling, there is no compensation for UK PlayStation customers, and nothing changes in Germany anyway. The PlayStation Store remains the only shop for digital games on the console, and the 30 percent commission also stays. So, anyone who has pre-ordered GTA 6 as the most pre-ordered game on the PlayStation Store will continue to pay Sony's prices.
However, the issue is not entirely off the table. Similar lawsuits are still ongoing in Australia, the Netherlands, and Portugal, according to Insider Gaming, with Kotaku also naming Mexico. These proceedings are partly in early stages and could have different outcomes.
One point of the judgment's reasoning, however, seems to be on borrowed time: The argument about physical games holds true only as long as discs are actually available. Already today, some major titles are released only as a code in a box, as our guide to the digital version and code-in-a-box for GTA 6 shows. The more discs disappear, the weaker this justification becomes. Should the matter go to court again in a few years, this is likely to be the opposing side's leverage.
Source: The Game Business, Kotaku, Insider Gaming, Court of Appeal (Judgment of July 4, 2025)
Do you agree with the verdict, or would you like to see alternative stores on the PS5?



Comments (0)
No comments yet — be the first to share your take.