Nintendo and review-bombing? That's a rare combination. But it's happening now with Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy: On Metacritic, the critic score stands at a respectable 83 points, while the user score has plummeted to 2.3. This earns it the label "Generally Unfavourable" – for a title whose main game many consider the best Pikmin entry ever.
The upgrade has been available since last week and costs €9.99 (or £7.99 / $9.99 USD) as a paid add-on. For this price, players get 4K graphics in TV mode, the new Dandori Academy challenge mode, and a few extras like voice commands. It's precisely this value proposition that has many fans up in arms.
Why does Pikmin 4 on Switch 2 have such poor user ratings?
Hundreds of scathing reviews are piling up on the Metacritic page for the Switch 2 Edition. The criticism boils down to three main points:
- Recycled levels: The Dandori Academy is supposed to offer six new challenges each month, for which players can submit best times on specific weekends. According to an analysis by YouTuber Press A!, however, some of the “new” levels are only slightly altered caves from the main game – some simply rotated. Others originate from the old Dandori mode or are reconfigured campaign areas.
- No 60 fps mode, no mouse control: Many had firmly expected the Switch 2 to deliver more here. No such luck.
- Longer loading times: Ironically, loading times are sometimes longer on the more powerful hardware. Press A! measured over 30 seconds when exiting a cave, compared to around 6 seconds in the original. Nintendo Life conducted its own measurements and found 14 to 15 seconds – less dramatic, but still more than twice as long.
One user describes the Switch 2 Edition as "essentially worthless," while another calls it more of a downgrade than an upgrade. For comparison: The Switch 2 remake of Zelda: Ocarina of Time currently holds the highest Metacritic user score of all time with 9.6. It's a long way from there to 2.3.

What the press says about Dandori Academy
Professional critics are much more relaxed about it. Nintendo Life awarded 7 out of 10 points, also expressing frustration over the lack of mouse control and 60 fps, but considering the price appropriate for what's offered. IGN News Editor Tom Phillips also enjoyed the initial Dandori courses but admitted that more could have been done – especially for a series that aims to attract new fans rather than alienate existing ones.
Paid Switch 2 upgrades: Pikmin 4 hits a sore spot
The frustration isn't truly surprising. Nintendo has been charging for its Switch 2 Editions since the console's launch, while other publishers often upgrade their games for new hardware for free. With Pikmin 4, the added value heavily relies on the Dandori Academy – and that delivers its content in small doses, sometimes with familiar maps. An upgrade that feels like a receipt for recycled content in its first few days is an open invitation for review bombers.
Nevertheless, a 2.3 says more about the sentiment than the game's quality. Pikmin 4 remains an excellent strategy game, and the loading times are an issue that Nintendo can address with a patch. Our advice for anyone still hesitant: Wait to see if an update fixes the loading times and if the next Dandori packs are truly fresh. Anyone who followed the Pikmin Day Direct with all announcements for Pikmin 4 also knows that Nintendo actively maintains the series. The fact that the Switch 2 is fundamentally capable of mouse control is demonstrated by the Joy-Con 2 mouse control that Minecraft is getting on Switch 2 – yet it's missing in Pikmin 4.
Source: Nintendo Life, IGN, Metacritic
Did you get the Pikmin 4 upgrade for €9.99 – and are your loading times also so sluggish?



Comments (0)
No comments yet — be the first to share your take.