It was supposed to be a celebratory post: On November 13, Xbox Content Chief Matt Booty took to LinkedIn to commemorate the 25th anniversary of Halo. However, according to Destructoid, several former Halo developers, including previous art directors for the series, responded to the post. Instead of congratulations, there was criticism of Xbox's direction and Booty personally.
What are the ex-Halo developers accusing Matt Booty of?
Glenn Israel, former Art Director for Halo, was the most vocal. According to Destructoid, he essentially wrote that Booty could, for the 25th anniversary, explain how and why he “shielded” Pierre Hintze while Hintze, in Israel’s view, “unethically and unlawfully” drove the franchise and studio into the ground. The post continued verbatim: “You’ve known for years about the multiple violations, the broken contracts, the collapsing morale – people were contacting you personally – and you did nothing.” According to Israel’s account, Booty had known about violations, broken contracts, and plummeting morale for years and did nothing.
Hintze had previously faced criticism: Destructoid refers to earlier allegations that his allegedly “cruel” behavior towards developers at Halo Studios was partly responsible for the series' decline. Israel himself had also spoken out previously, stating that he had witnessed or been subjected to numerous “unethical and/or unlawful” actions, including blacklisting, compensation fraud, favoritism, and harassment campaigns. These allegations cannot be independently verified.
Justin Dinges, also a former Art Director, was more concise: “Didn’t you just lay off most of Halo Studios?” Israel followed up, referring to “half of iD Software” and the “soon-to-be six thousand families” who, he claimed, would suffer from Xbox’s mismanagement this holiday season. Josh Rife from Halo’s World Art team summed it up in one sentence: Booty was “nothin’ but a suit.”

Halo at Activision: Why the anger is boiling over now
The frustration isn't entirely out of the blue. In September, Booty confirmed in an internal memo that Xbox was cutting over 250 more jobs, many of them at Halo Studios, as Kotaku reported at the time. Simultaneously, it became known that Halo Studios (formerly 343 Industries) would no longer develop the next main game, but rather a new team at Activision. What remains of the studio is only intended to support the series. Even then, many former Halo personnel reacted with disbelief – Dinges’ question directly alludes to this.
It's no coincidence that the anger is erupting specifically under an anniversary post. For the 25th anniversary of Xbox and Halo, Microsoft is currently celebrating its own legacy – with remakes, anniversary hardware, and plenty of nostalgia. For people who helped build this legacy and are now out of the picture, such a post apparently feels like rubbing salt in the wound. Our assessment: This is definitely a PR problem for Xbox, as the criticism doesn't come from anonymous accounts but from individuals with names and long Halo résumés. However, only a thorough investigation can clarify whether there is any truth to the substantive allegations.
Gameplay-wise, Halo continues nonetheless: Halo: Campaign Evolved will receive Firefight as a free update this winter, and around the anniversary, the anniversary Xbox Series X sold out in seconds.
Has Microsoft commented on the allegations?
Not yet. Destructoid mentions no reaction from Booty or Xbox, and our research also found no statement from Microsoft regarding the comments from Israel, Dinges, and Rife. Should this change, we will update accordingly.
Source: Destructoid, Kotaku
Is Halo at Activision an opportunity for you, or the final end for the old Halo soul?



Comments (0)
No comments yet — be the first to share your take.