Reviews Roundup & Opinion

GTA 6 in Review: Metascore 99 – Rockstar Ties Ocarina of Time

The review embargo has lifted, and the result is historic: Grand Theft Auto VI stands at a Metascore of 99 on Metacritic. Rockstar thus draws level with The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time, which was previously the only game to achieve this score.

The reviews went live punctually with the midnight launch in New Zealand, which was Wednesday noon German time. The game will be released for us tomorrow, November 19, for PS5 and Xbox Series X/S. A PC version is still not announced.

What scores is GTA 6 receiving in reviews?

In short: almost exclusively top scores. At the end of the embargo, the Metascore stood at 99 from around 100 reviews, according to Insider Gaming. ComputerBase counted 123 reviews shortly after, with an unchanged 99 points. According to PC Games Hardware, not a single score is below 90.

  • Metacritic: 99 (as of Wednesday afternoon, over 120 reviews)
  • IGN: Highest score – reviewer Luke Reilly calls GTA 6 the most impressive game he has ever played
  • GameSpot: Highest score, praising the richness of detail in the game world above all else
  • PC Games: 10 out of 10
  • GamePro: the highest score the magazine has ever awarded in its history
  • Slant: 4.5 out of 5 – the only non-perfect score in PC Gamer's overview, yet full of praise
  • New York Times, Guardian, Bloomberg: no numerical score, but consistently enthusiastic

For comparison: Rockstar's previous record holder was GTA 4 with 98 points. GTA 5 and GTA 3 scored 97, while Vice City and San Andreas each received 95. GTA 6 is thus the highest-rated Rockstar game ever.

Leonida as a new benchmark for open worlds

The reason for the record scores is consistent across almost all reviews: the game world. Leonida, Rockstar's version of Florida, is described as the most vibrant and detailed open world to date. According to ComputerBase, Eurogamer highlights that practically nothing repeats itself there. GameSpot speaks of a giant haystack full of needles, where you constantly find new details.

The relationship between Jason and Lucia is also extremely well received. The New York Times calls GTA 6 a game about love and relationships, while The Guardian writes of the medium's “greatest love story.” GamePro additionally praises the varied main missions, many freedoms during heists, 23 radio stations, over 50 weapons, more than 200 vehicles, and over 100 animals.

Where does GTA 6 fall short, according to critics?

It's not entirely without criticism, although the points are minor:

  • 30 FPS on consoles: Despite this, the performance impressions at launch are reassuring, according to Notebookcheck. Digital Foundry, as reported by Notebookcheck, measured occasional drops below 30 FPS, but the controls remain responsive.
  • Story pacing: According to ComputerBase, Push Square finds the story drags a bit towards the end, while TheSixthAxis feels the constant escalation sometimes causes a loss of focus.
  • Controls: GamePro notes that the cover system can be a bit fiddly in places.
  • Traffic: Vice City is sometimes so full of cars and pedestrians, according to Notebookcheck, that missions are slowed down.

There are varying reports on playtime: GamePro mentions around 50 hours for the main story, while Notebookcheck states some reviews report approximately 60 hours. IGN reviewer Reilly had 120 hours on the clock by the credits and had not yet seen the entire map.

Why 99 is more than just a number

A small caveat is necessary: As ComputerBase notes, not all reviews listed on Metacritic have a clear numerical score. Reviews without a number are included in the average as 100 percent. This doesn't change the overall picture, but the 99 is also partly a matter of mathematics.

We find something else more exciting. After a 13-year wait, several delays, and a hype that no game could realistically fulfill, the obvious expectation was a “very good, but.” Instead, reviewers are praising precisely the points where large open-world games usually fail: variety, density, and a world that reacts to the player. The 30 FPS is the only real compromise, and that was known since Rockstar's official 30 FPS confirmation. The question now is how players will judge: user scores are still locked on Metacritic and, according to Notebookcheck, will only be possible 36 hours after release. Whether GTA 6 will also sweep the Game Awards in December, where it enters the race with eight nominations, is hardly a question after these scores.

Screenshot from GTA 6: Lucia aims a pistol, with the skyscrapers of Vice City in the background
Image source: Rockstar Games, official press material
Screenshot from GTA 6: A couple sits on a pickup truck under a large tree at sunset, deer graze, with the hazy skyline behind them
Image source: Rockstar Games, official press material

Source: Metacritic, Insider Gaming, PC Gamer, ComputerBase, PC Games Hardware, GamePro, Notebookcheck

Do you believe GTA 6 can maintain the 99 with players, or do you expect review bombing after launch due to the 30 FPS?

Comments (0)

No comments yet — be the first to share your take.